Sunday, November 17, 2013


Flood Insurance- Biggert Waters May Bring Some Big Changes

The passage of the Biggert Waters Act ("BWA") will bring some changes to the overall administration of loans in a flood zone for all banks.  However, for Banks with a sound compliance program for flood insurance the changes should be absorbed easily.  While some of the changes will be implemented through regulations, other changes are effective immediately.  In our opinion, the best approach is to start to address all of the changes immediately.

Force Placed Insurance Changes Required  by the Act

The FDPA has always required that when lenders determine that insurance is either inadequate or about to expire, borrowers must be notified immediately.  The lender is also required to force place insurance on the borrowers property if the borrowers fails to purchase the required insurance with 45 days after receiving notice.   One of the new provisions in the regulation addresses one of the areas of confusion that was part of this process.  Under the new provisions of the Act, the lender can charge fees that cover the complete time period from when the insurance lapsed or was deemed insufficient.   In other words, the fees that Banks can charge can go all the way back to the date that the insurance expired or was found to be inadequate. 

A second provision of the Act deals with lenders responsibility upon receiving notice that the borrower has purchased their own insurance.  Banks are directed  that they have 30 days to terminate a forced placed policy and refund fees for insurance that overlaps with the borrowers insurance.   

The changes to the Act also help to clear up another area that had caused some confusion; the documentation that the lender can use to prove that  insurance is in force.  According to the Act a declarations  page that has the insurance policy number as well as contact information for the insurance agent will be sufficient.    In the past, many regulators were requiring an actual binder before Banks could satisfy the documentation requirements.  

It is worth noting that these changes take place without the need for further regulations.  

Civil Money Penalties

In the past, one of the least scary parts of the flood insurance compliance was the fact that the civil money penalties that could be assessed were, quite frankly, very small.   This slap-on-the-wrist benefit has significantly been changed.  Individual penalties for violations can now be as large as $2,000 and the penalty cap per year has been removed.  In the unfortunate situation where examiners find a pattern and practice of violations, then civil money penalties can now become quite high!    

This section of the law will become active without  further regulations. 

Private Flood Insurance

One area of significant change is that Banks are now directed to accept private flood insurance  to meet the requirements of the regulation.  This is not to say that the insurance has to be private, but if the basic requirements of the Act are met, then private insurance can and should be accepted.  As a part of this provision, Banks will be expected to provide a notice to borrowers that will include  at least the following information:

·         That flood insurance is available from both private insurers and from the NFIP directly;

·         Flood Insurance that provides the same level of coverage as the NFIP is available privately:

·         Borrowers should shop around for the best deal

The best news here is that these provisions will not be effective until final regulations have been implemented.  However, proposed regulations have been submitted for public comment and there is nothing in the proposed regulations that appears to change the notification requirements.  

Escrow Requirements

One of the areas of largest departure from the past is a requirement that Banks establish an escrow account for payment of flood insurance for improved reals estate loans when the improvements are in a flood area.   These requirements will apply to all Banks that are larger than $1 billion in assets as of July 6, 2014. 

Managing Change

For our clients that already have a sound system for administering the flood insurance portfolio, these changes should create very little consternation.  The notice requirements for force-placed insurance should already be in place be a part of the ongoing practice of administering these loans.  However, now would be an excellent time to review your current policies and procedures to make sure that they do in fact detail what should be done when staff discover that insurance is either insufficient, or will soon expire.   

Now is also a great time to review the process for following up when a customer notifies the Bank that they did in fact obtain satisfactory insurance.  It appears that the new provisions of the BWA will create some liability for banks that do not respond by canceling forced placed insurance and refunding any money for overlapping coverage.   The systems in place must help the Bank respond quickly and accurately.  

We note that while final regulations are now being proposed, both the civil money penalty and forced placed provisions of the Act are considered self- enacting.  

Tuesday, November 12, 2013


The importance of a Consumer Compliance program at a Non consumer Bank

We often hear the familiar refrain “we really don’t make any consumer loans except the occasional accommodation for a good customer – so we really don’t need a compliance officer or a compliance program.”  For many a bank this conclusion can seem straight forward and logical.  However, nothing could be further from the truth! 

The Intersection of Consumer and Commercial Lending

Though it may not seem apparent a first glance, there are a number of ways that consumer regulations can creep into the overall operation of banks that consider themselves, non-consumer.    First, there are a number of consumer oriented regulations that apply to all lending, not just commercial lending.  In addition, certain types of commercial lending still have a consumer aspect to it.  For example, commercial loans to buy apartments may need to be reported under the Home Mortgage Disclosure Act (HMDA).  Finally it has become increasingly clear that regulators like the CFPB are willing to use broad interpretations of consumer regulations to increase the impact and influence of these regulations.  [1]

Among all of the consumer regulations with the biggest potential impact on commercial lending is Regulation B which is the implementing regulation for the law known as the Equal credit Opportunity Act.  The requirements of regulation B apply to ALL loans, not just consumer loans.   The requirement to make a credit decision within 30 days of receiving a completed application and giving proper notification of adverse action are well known portions of the regulation.  However, it is important to note that there are several other portions of this law that must be considered.  For example, Regulation B specifically prohibits discouragement of an applicant.  It also prohibits a bank form refusing to grant credit based upon marital status or from discounting government income.    Though this regulation has in the past generally only been applied to consumer lending, there is nothing in the regulation that could or would prevent regulators from applying it to commercial lending.  

In point of fact, Reg. B is actually the heart and soul of fair lending regulations.   When reviewing a Banks compliance with Fair Lending, one of the main considerations that regulator will make is whether or not fair and equal consideration is being given to all applicants.  The guidelines in Regulations B are used to determine whether or not a Bank’s credit process is being is designed to deliver outcomes that do not have disparate impact.  

 In addition to Reg. B and Fair lending considerations, all banks must meet the requirements of the Community Reinvestment Act.  Even for a small community bank the requirements of the act include identifying the credit needs of the assessment area and making a majority of loans within that area.  These requirements put, at a minimum, the onus on a Bank to be able to document why being a commercial loan only lender meets the credit needs of its community.  In other words, it is fair game for examiners to ask a bank to document how its decision to refrain from making consumer loans is a business decision and not one that has disparate impact.

Yet another area where the CFPB and by implication other regulatory agencies have shown a willingness to apply consumer based regulations across the board is the Unfair Deceptive, Abusive Acts or practices regulation commonly known as UDAAP.  The fact is that the practices or policies that may violate this rule are really in the eye of the beholder.  Therefore the possible ranges of practices that may violate this law are widespread.  Based upon current experiences of banks, it appears that products that have complicated or high fee schedules often come under close scrutiny here.  Even banks that are commercial loan only status can run afoul of UDAAP. 

HMDA is another consumer based regulation that has impact on all banks.  In cases, where a commercial loan includes the purchase of a dwelling unit, reporting may be required if your bank is a HMDA reporter.  So for example, where the borrower is purchasing a retail space that includes six condominiums, there may very like be the need to record the dwelling units on your HMDA LAR!  It is also clear that at some time in the very near future, Banks will be asked to compile information on loans to women and minority owned business in a manner that will mirror the information that is currently collected for the HMDA LAR. 

Consumer Regulations Apply 

Ultimately, there is no such thing as a Bank or financial institution that can completely avoid consumer regulations.   Therefore, as your bank begins to prepare its risk assessment consumer compliance must be part of the consideration.  Moreover, the decision to allocate little to no resources in this area can be one that a Bank will come to regret in the future.    One of the main reasons firms like ours exist is to assist community banks that have made the decision to de-emphasize consumer lending maintain a strong compliance program nevertheless.    

While the compliance management program at a commercial loan only bank does not need to be as extensive as a bank that has a great deal of activity, the basic components of the program are the same.  There have to be policies and procedures established by the Board of Directors that detail the standards for compliance, management information systems that monitor for compliance, internal controls and monitoring  and training for compliance.  Without these basic pillars, a compliance program will be inadequate and potential trouble for any bank. 

The compliance program at a Bank that is largely non consumer can quickly and easily be the first line of defense against significant enforcement actions.  Oftentimes, when consumer compliance is not a large part of the daily operation of a bank, the requirements of the regulations often go unnoticed.  Even the basic requirement of notice within 30 days can slip or flood Insurance that is required can be overlooked.  In an instant, the one area that in which the Bank thought there would never be a problem; consumer compliance,  becomes a colossal headache!  

Regardless of the size of your bank or the level of intensity of consumer lending, a need will always exist for a compliance management program.    



[1] Recent actions against automobile lenders, credit card marketers and mortgage insurance brokers all serve as examples.  

Monday, November 4, 2013


Will the “Ability to Repay” Rules Create a Fair Lending Risk?  

Of the many regulations that will be implemented in 2014, one of the most talked about is the “ability to repay”   rule.  This rule requires banks to make a good faith effort to determine a borrower’s ability to repay a loan before the credit is extended. The rule specifies the type of documentation that is required to meet the standards set.  The rule also establishes a “safe harbor” that allows banks to be presumed to make loans that meet the standards of the regulation as long as the bank makes “qualifying loans”.  Essentially qualified mortgages are loans that are not deemed higher priced.[1] 

Generally, the decision has been made by banks that the best way to avoid the ability to repay rules is to simply make only qualifying mortgages.  For many banks, making the decision to originate only qualified mortgages also means reducing the type of products being offered and potentially the volume of consumer mortgages.  Some of our clients have asked then, whether or not the decision to offer only qualified mortgages will create a Fair Lending concern. 

The good news is that the regulatory agencies that comprised the FFIEC have issued a statement on this very topic.  [2]  At first glance it appears that the statement clearly tells banks that issuing only qualified mortgages should not be a Fair Lending concern. 

“…the Agencies do not anticipate that a creditor’s decision to offer only Qualified Mortgages would, absent other factors, elevate a supervised institution’s fair lending risk” [3]

However, we advise that the emphasis has to be placed on the words absent other factors.  And in fact, the statement goes on to describe what some of the other factors might be.   The statement makes clear that banks and financial institutions are always required to follow safe and sound practices when making loans.  And in point of fact, despite wide spread belief to the contrary, there is nothing in consumer regular that requires banks to make lower quality loans.   For example, the preamble to the Community Reinvestment Act specifically reminds banks that all loans should be made with safety and soundness as basic considerations.     

However, Fair Lending and its   regulations are a different “brand of cat” from other consumer regulations.   When reviewing a Bank’s compliance in the area of Fair Lending, regulators will consider not just compliance with the letter of the law, but also the impact that policies and practices have on members of the bank’s assessment area.   Therefore, the decision to make a certain type of loan or to cease offering a product can be totally in compliance with the requirements all consumer regulations.  However, the impact could be disproportionate to members of the banks customer base.  For example, suppose a bank decides to stop offering second mortgages, of longer than 5 years in length.   This decision is neutral on its face as it appears to impact all potential borrowers at the bank in the same manner.  However, if a study is completed that finds that this decision resulted in a reduction of all applicants that are in protected classes, there could be a Fair Lending concern.  The impact of the decision had a disparate impact on the borrowers from protect classes that reside in the bank’s assessment area. 

It is important to note that a practice can have a disparate impact and still not be a Fair Lending concern.  If the practice meets a legitimate business need that cannot reasonable be achieved in a manner that has less disparate impact, then the Fair Lending test is met.  [4]  The point here is that there must be some research done and documentation that there is a specific business purpose for the practice.  The decision discussed above can have the disparate impact that we described, but if the bank that made the decision can also show that there for example a direct relationship between the loan terms and its funding sources, there is likely a strong business reason for the decision. 

The interagency statement makes it clear that the same standard will be used to determine whether a bank’s decision to offer only qualified mortgages is a matter for Fair Lending concern.  As the statement notes, there are several ways that a financial institution can qualify for the safe harbor status including selling mortgages to federal agencies such as Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.  Therefore, a decision to cease certain products without considering how they may still be qualified mortgages may not be received favorably by the regulators.   

In our opinions banks should not simply and arbitrarily decide to make only qualified mortgages in an attempt to meet the ability to repay rules.  A more thorough consideration is required.  Thought must be given to how this decision fits in with the strategic plan of the bank as well as the impact on the surrounding community.   Complete documentation of the business reasons why the decision is being made is critical to defending against claims of disparate impact or unfair practices.  




[1] Higher-priced loans are generally defined as having an annual percentage rate (APR) that, as of the date the interest rate is set, exceeds the Average Prime Offer Rate (APOR) by 1.5 percentage points or more for first-lien loans and 3.5 percentage points or more for subordinate-lien loans
[2] CA 13-15 Interagency Statement on Fair Lending Compliance and the Ability-to-Repay and Qualified Mortgage Standards Rule
[3] Ibid
[4] Ibid

Monday, October 21, 2013



Marketing to Your Entire Community

One of the key elements in the overall commercial success of a bank is its ability to market itself to its community.  It is through marketing that the bank lets their communities know that it is around and that it is open for business.   Putting a marketing plan together can sometimes be a daunting task indeed.  This is especially true in the current cost conscious environment.  As you put you marketing plans together we suggest that there are two other areas to consider-both Fair Lending and the Community Reinvestment Act.  Your banks’ overall effort at compliance in these two areas can be either greatly enhanced or harmed by the marketing that is done.   We suggest that marketing should always be directed at the client’s entire community.  Failure to include all potential customers in marketing can result in both missed opportunities and the potential for CRA and Fair Lending issues.

Just What IS Your Entire Community?

The first step in the process is to make a determination of just who is part of the entire community that that your bank serves!  When was the last time that you performed an assessment of the communities that make up your assessment area? There is a wealth of information available about the makeup of people who live in your assessment area.  For example, the US Census Bureau publishes information about the households in the tracts in your assessment area.  The inform information includes statistics on the median income, age and races on the people in your area.  There is also information on minority and business ownership that is available by county and MSA.  The FFIEC website has a link to the Census Bureau.[1]  Another good source of data is reports prepared by county and state Chambers of Commerce. In addition to public sources of information, there are several services that provide economic data about the economic status of counties and communities[2]. However, it should be noted that these services tend to be expensive.

A much better source of information is personal contact with community groups in your area. Not all community organizers are anti-banks! In point of fact, many are doing all they can to get their clients actively involved in the banking community and away from the clutches of ‘’payday’’ lenders.

The goal here is to develop as much information as possible about just who your community is and how they fit into your business plan.  Oftentimes, this process results in discovering new and heretofore untapped opportunities. One of the main thrusts of CRA that often goes unmentioned is the push to get banks to find lending opportunities that would go completely unnoticed if not for requirements of the regulation.   Remember, CRA specifically states that the intention is not to get banks to make bad loans, just loans that would otherwise be overlooked[3]

 

Why Should a Bank Market to the Entire Community?

The obvious answer to this question is that failure to market to the whole community may result in a violation of CRA or Fair Lending.  The exclusion of one or more protected groups form marketing efforts can easily be interpreted as a form of “redlining” or discouragement, both of which would be seriously regulatory compliance problems.   

The less obvious answer is that by including the entire community of your field of customers, the Bank can become a significant part of the community.  Community banks are an indispensable part of any community. Though it may not seem this way, the trend is that the regulatory agencies are beginning to recognize that community banks are an indispensable part of small communities and should be treated that way.  [4] The more that the bank can show that it is truly serving the needs of its community, the stronger the argument becomes that it is indispensable.  An indispensable bank is one that communities will fight for in times of trouble. Moreover, regulators are more likely to give assistance to true community banks

Yet another consideration is the possibility of finding ‘’jewels in the rough’’ within underserved and under banked communities. This is the business model that has been pursued with a great deal of success by Magic Johnson Enterprises among others[5]

How to Market

Today there are so many different venues for advertising that provide for effective low cost communication with customers that the bank opportunities are limitless. Social media has become a staple of the advertising for many banks. Good old fashion newspaper advertising works for others.  The idea is to make sure that you strive for inclusion and meet people where they are.  Do people speak different foreign languages in your assessment area? Make sure that you reach out to them in publications aimed at serving these communities. 

 

In the end, comprehensive marketing programs serve both compliance and the bottom line.



[1] http://www.ffiec.gov/; http://www.econdata.net/content_datacollect.html
[2] Dun & Bradstreet provides one such service
[3] The Community Reinvestment Act of 1977 instructs federal financial supervisory agencies to encourage their regulated financial institutions to help meet credit needs of the communities in which they are chartered while also conforming to “safe and sound” lending standards.
[4] See Oklahoma Bankers association update June 3, 20123; 2011 Speech by  Ben Bernanke to federal Reserve Board
[5] From the website of MJ enterprises: Magic Johnson Enterprises serves as a catalyst for driving unparalleled business results for our partners and fostering community/economic empowerment by making available high-quality entertainment, products and services that answer the demands of ethnically diverse urban communities

Sunday, October 13, 2013


Special Considerations for Freezing or Reducing HELOCs

 During the worst part of the great recession, one of the things that many of our clients did to reduce risk was to freeze or reduce credit lines on open-ended credit. Many credit providers too this unpopular stand as a risk avoidance strategy. More and more, consumers were shocked to find that their credit lines were reduced to an amount that was close to the outstanding balance even though the credit is in good standing. 

Home Equity Loans (HELOCs) are traditionally some of the largest open-end credits and, unfortunately, some of the most dramatically affected by market conditions. As the market values of homes all over the country continued to fall, many banks took the stand that the most prudent thing to do was to reduce credit lines to reflect the new, lower value of the home that is being used as collateral for the loan.

While establishing a program for reducing or freezing HELOCs may be a prudent business practice, banks should closely consider the Fair Lending and CRA implications of such a program, before aggressively pursuing it.  This is especially true in light of the ongoing emphasis that is being placed on Fair Lending in in 2013 and beyond. 

Regulatory Considerations  

While the trend of reducing credit is highly un-popular, banks are well within their rights to pursue this action. For example, Regulation Z allows a bank to alter a home equity loan program when the underlying property has experienced a “significant decrease in value”[1]. The regulation details the rules for determining whether a significant decrease in collateral value has occurred and specifies the means for reinstating credit once the collateral value returns. 

On the other hand, banks need to be careful to be aware that the decisions that they make may trigger further disclosures. For example, Regulation B requires that when an unfavorable change in an account occurs that does not affect an entire class of customers, an adverse action has occurred. [2] In other words, the decision to reduce or freeze individual accounts due to a reduction in collateral value is an adverse action and triggers a Regulation B adverse action notice.

 Fair Lending Considerations 

However, the places where foreclosures are taking place and where real estate values are declining can often be in places where large concentrations of protected groups reside. [3] In addition, the decision to reduce HELOCs can have a disproportionate impact on a certain segment of the customer base. 

For example, suppose a bank’s HELOC marketing program had been targeted at its woman owned business or the Hispanic segment of its customer base.  A decision to reduce or freeze these HELOCs could result in a large protected class of the customer base disproportionately impacted. This is the type of situation that was at the root of a lawsuit filed by the city of Baltimore, Maryland against Wells Fargo Bank where two thirds of the foreclosures in that city were in census tracts where African Americans represented 60 percent or more of the population.[4]    It is also current a cause celebre  in the current case of the city of Richmond, California, where the city is using the powers of imminent domain to take houses from the banks that are attempting to foreclose.  Regardless of the outcome of these cases, the overall reputation of the banks that are involved will be greatly diminished. 

It is critically important that the bank consider the consumer protection implications of a program to freeze or cancel products.  Fair lending is one of the areas of regulation where mere compliance with the letter of the law does not necessary reduce risk.  The impact of policies and procedures are widely considered as part of a comprehensive fair lending examination.  As a result, the impact that business decisions have on traditionally underserved communities can, and will be considered.  The business or economic reasons for the decision to proceed with or cease products should be well documented to protect against accusations of unfair or illegal lending practices.
Conclusion

Tough economic times often call for unusual measures. It is in these times that the goals of safety and soundness run headlong into consumer protections. While programs to reduce or freeze HELOCs can make perfect economic sense, the potential for reputation and or legal risk to the bank can outweigh the benefits.    




[1] [1] Defined as 50% of the equity of the underlying property at Staff Commentary of Regulation Z  at 226.5b(f)(3)vi
[2] [2]This revision emphasized that the exception applies only when the creditor’s action is not based on the individual credit characteristics of the affected accountholders. For example, the exception would apply where a creditor terminates all secured credit accounts because it no longer offers that type of credit. Federal Register / Vol. 68, No. 52 / Tuesday, March 18, 2003 / Rules and Regulations
[3]  Declining Market Policies Have Disparate Impact On Minorities, Lower Income Neighborhoods, Reuters  Apr 1, 2008 6:30am EDT
 
[4] [4][4] Everyone's Feeling Economic Pain, But It's Hitting Minorities Worst of All. By Valeria Fernandez , ColorLines January 19, 2009
 

Sunday, October 6, 2013


Assessing the Credit Needs of Your Community 

One of the basic tenants of compliance with the Community Reinvestment Act (“CRA”) is that a financial institution should strive to “meet the credit needs of its community”.  Despite this requirement, there has never been  clear definition or guidance on how Banks should systematically determine what those needs are.  We believe that the lack of a clear definition in this area presents both a problem and a an opportunity.  Ultimately, we believe that the Bank that can demonstrate that it has a clear understanding of credit needs vis- a-vis the products that it offers will present a strong case for compliance not only with CRA but also Fair Lending and UDAAP.  We suggest the following approach. 

Step One:    Develop Basic Economic Data.

There is a great deal of public economic data that is available for each and every census tract in the United States.  We suggest that at a minimum, that your economic research should include the following information:

·         The median Income for the assessment area

·         The median housing prices for the assessment area

·         The largest employers in the county that comprises the bulk of your assessment area

·         Information on the business and business owners in the county (in particular, women and minority ownership)

·         Information on whether or not there are economically distressed areas within your assessment area.   [1]

The idea here is to be able to tell a story about the economic conditions that exist in your assessment  area.  Using this information, you can make a generalization about what the typical potential borrower at your bank will look like in economic terms.  Local and county chambers of commerce generally will prepare economic predictions that can be used to analyze  trends in the area.  Finally, community groups in your area often have economic information that can be very useful for development of an economic picture.   With all of this information, you can start to tell a story about the potential borrowing needs in the community.    For example, the information can show that business is growing in certain sectors in the area, which will imply a need for SBA or asset-based lending.  It is important to be expansive in your description of the credit needs in the assessment area.  Remember, just because a certain type of lending is a need in the community, it does not create a requirement that your bank should offer these types of loans.  The point of this exercise is to show that your bank is aware of the credit needs of the community .  

Telling the Bank’s Story

The second step is to develop the economic story of the bank. It is critically important to reflect on the raison d’etre  for the bank.  Why is your bank in existence and who is the basic customer base?   Although the answer to this question may seem obvious to those who have been a part of your bank for some time, it is at all obvious to the outsiders who will be reviewing the CRA performance of your bank!    Moreover, this is a good starting point for the comparison that is necessary to do a strong assessment of the credit needs of the community.   How do the goals of the bank match up with the credit needs of the community?  In many cases, communities have changed significantly since banks opened.  Events that range from economic calamities and technological innovations have cause many communities to shift in overall makeup.   What was once a small agricultural community can quickly become a mecca for software development.   While the goals of the bank can remain steadfast, the way that those goals are met can change.  

Take a look at the list of products that are offered at the bank and start to see how they match up with the economic profile that you developed in phase one.  As part of this process, it is a best practice to compare the economic profiles used by the bank as minimum guidelines with the profiles of the assessment area.  For example, suppose your bank has set a minimum level of disposable income acceptable to make a loan.  Does that minimum reflect current economic conditions in your community.  We recently consulted with a bank that had set a minimum of $2,300 a month in disposable income for its consumer loans.  The standard was applied equally across all consumer applications.  However, because  this minimum level was set at a time when the economy in the assessment area was strong, it did not reflect the current conditions of a great deal of the population that immediately surrounded the bank.  As a result, the bank was not lending to the majority of its customers. 

In the above example, the fact that the banks standards resulted in few loans in the area surrounding its main office was not the actual problem,  remember, neither CRA or Fair Lending laws require banks to make bad loans or even loans that they don’t feel are desirable.  The problem was that the Bank could not present economic justification for the $2,300 disposable income limit.  It was more of a custom than an economic consideration.  If there had been some sort of research that showed that this was the considered business decision of the Board based upon the study of the community, there would have little to no concern on the part of the regulators.  In this case unfortunately, without the evidence they needed the bank was faced with potential enforcement action.  

The goal in telling the bank’s economic story is to compare economic conditions in the assessment area with the goals and the  economic realities at the bank.  A community may have a strong need for mortgages, but if your bank doesn’t have mortgage lending staff, or if the Board has determined that its risk appetite does not include mortgages, then there is a good business decision why this product is not offered.   The fact that mortgage loans have been identified and legitimately eliminated as a product is a very strong case for compliance with the CRA!. 

Dynamic Assessment is a Key

The area of greatest risk that we come across is the failure of banks to make their risk assessments a dynamic process.  We recommend for our clients that they make the risk assessment of the credit needs of the community an annual process.  By doing so, the current trends become part of the assessment can be updated with an eye towards making changes as is necessary.  We also strongly recommend that our banks include community groups and local trade organizations a part of the process.   This can easily be accomplished by the use of surveys and interviews.   The idea is to use the most current information available to establish a clear and accurate view of the community. 

Product develop should take place with an eye towards trends in the community.  While the bank does not have to meet all of the needs of its community, there should be an effort to determine how new and developing products fit in with the current and developing needs in a  community. 

The CRA does not require a bank to meet ALL of the credit needs of it community, but the prudent bank is aware of those needs so that in the future as products changes, these needs are considered. 



[1] All of this information is available on the FFIEC website. 

Monday, September 30, 2013


Pitfalls to Avoid When Developing a Risk Assessment for Fair Lending- Part Two

In part one of this series, we made the argument that a risk assessment should be performed individually for the area of Fair Lending.   When performing the risk assessment there are several pitfalls that must be avoided. 

Policies and Procedures

The review of the bank’s policies and particularly, its procedures is a basic and critical part to any risk assessment in the area of Fair Lending.     

Potential Pitfall:  Policies and procedures can be fully in compliance with regulatory requirements and still have the potential for Fair Lending issues.  Review of the policies and procedures must consider both compliance with the requirements of regulations and the impact on customers!

First these documents should be reviewed to determine that all of the required information is up to date and correct.  In this review, it is important that regulatory requirements such as “grossing” up, spousal signature rules and Fair Lending principles are included.  This review should also include view of procedures to ensure that they match policies.  

The second phase of the review should be completed to ensure that policies and procedures do not present the possibility of disparate impact.  In this review, the goal is to review the policies and procedures to determine the level of discretion allowed and how this discretion can be checked against Fair Lending risk.  For example, do the procedures require documentation of delays in processing loans?  Do policies and procedures emphasize the need for secondary review?

 Credit Policies

Credit Policies are an area of particular concern in the Fair lending Assessment.  The review of credit policies should also be completed in two phases

Potential Pitfall: Credit policies should reflect the idea that the bank has made a reasoned decision about how it is meeting the credit needs of its community.  Policies that are fully compliant can become outdated quickly.  Review of credit policies should consider the changes in the assessment area and should reflect the business decisions of the Board.      

Credit formulas and guidelines should be reviewed and validated independently to ensure that the data is valid.   Though these validations don’t need to be performed annually, it is a best practice to test the guidelines Vis a Vis adverse action trends at the bank.  Guidelines that yield an extremely high number of loan declines may need study and possibly adjustment. 

In the second phase a comparison between the credit policies, the strategic plan of the bank and current economic data should be completed.  The purpose of this review is to determine that the bank’s credit policies and procedures match the credit needs of the community.   It is imperative that the Bank be able to document the business reasons for the list of products being offered.  For example, a decision by a Bank not to offer home equity loans when there is strong need for such loans in an assessment area, may be called into question during a Fair Lending examination.  A best practice is to have the economic data to show that these loans are not economically feasible at the bank. 

Credit Decision Process

The credit decision process from the time of application to ultimately credit decision or withdrawal by the applicant should be assessed with an eye towards eliminating the ability of single bank employee from thwarting the will of the Board by engaging in illegal behavior  

Potential Pitfall:  When reviewing adverse actions and withdrawals for timely notices, it is possible to overlook the warning signs of Fair Lending issues. 

The review of adverse actions generally includes a check to make sure that notices are given within the timeframes required by Regulation B.  In addition a good review includes a check to determine that the information given is sufficient for the applicant to understand the issues that cause an adverse decision.   However, a best practice is also to review for Fair Lending ‘warning signs”.  For example, an extremely low rate of adverse actions is a strong indicator or pre-screening.  A high rate of withdrawals among protected groups is a strong indicator of discouragement. 

It is a best practice to review the credit decision process to determine the ability of an individual to make credit decisions without oversight.  The more autonomy those loan officers have, the more the system for secondary review should be empowered.  

 Lending Decisions

The traditional Fair Lending analysis focuses on a review of the approvals versus declines at the Bank.  A common practice is to review “matched pairs” which compares the low rated credit approvals with highly rated declines (loans that were barely declined). 

Potential Pitfall:  If this is the heart of the analysis, then the bank is not getting the full story!  The analysis must look at the applicant’s total experience to ensure that all are getting the same considerations. 

The analysis should consider:  

·         Application to decision time-trends for members in protected classes
·         Comparative analysis- close decisions to approve versus decline
·         Pricing  Analysis
·         Special considerations
o   Insufficient collateral frequently being given as a reason for decline
o   Large number of declines in a certain product area
o   High number of approvals versus a small number of declines  

If all of the above is not part of the analysis that is being performed, then your bank may have potential Fair Lending issues that are going undetected.  

Vendor Management

Banks are being charged with knowing and managing the results obtained from their vendors.  The regulatory agencies have made it clear that in every area from indirect auto lending to appraisals, that they expect banks to monitor the results that they are getting form vendors. 

Potential Pitfall:  The review of vendors stops with a background check.  The best practices require that the Bank pay attention to the results of the vendor’s efforts.  There has to be a general check that results are reasonable and consistent

The assessment must consider whether the results being produced are consistent and reliable.  For example, are appraisals being reviewed and compared to complaints?   Is it possible that certain appraisers consistently yield lower property values in certain income tracts?  Are flood insurance determinations being updated to match changes in the flood map?  The bank will be held accountable for the misbehavior of its vendors!      

UDAAP Review

The risk assessment should include a review of the potential for UDAAP.  This is an area that is growing in scope and influence. 

Potential Pitfall:  UDAAP is far reaching and can be easily overlooked.  

The assessment should consider whether there is consistency in advertising and actual disclosures.  The risk assessment must look at the Bank’s products/operations from the point of view of the consumer. 

Customer complaints are an area of focus for regulators in the near future!  Make sure that complaints are getting categorized and reported to the Board.  If no complaints have been received, there should be at least a policy and procedures in place to handle these once they do appear!      

Advertising

Many community banks use testimonials as part of their marketing.  The relationship with the community is after all, one of the strengths of being a community bank. 

Potential Pitfall:   A risk assessment that exclusively covers direct compliance with Reg. Z and DD may overlook Fair Lending concerns in advertising. 

Risk assessment should cover the reasons for the advertising and the markets that you are attempting to reach.  Has the bank considered expanding advertising to nontraditional communities?   Are there communities within the Bank’s assessment area that are left out of the advertising and marketing? 

Strategic Plan

Examiners expect that the Bank has direct knowledge of the credit needs of the assessment area.  This should be considered as part of the risk assessment

Potential Pitfall:  Without considering the overall strategy of the Bank, it is difficult to get the full picture of how the bank is addressing Fair Lending within its community   

The strategic plan is most often not considered as part of the Fair Lending assessment.  However, it is clear that examiners will start considering a bank’s strategy in offering products to its community as a consideration of Fair Lending effectiveness. 

We believe that a Fair Lending risk assessment is a critical component of effective compliance management.